GREAT POWER POLITICS

9 December 2023

https://youtu.be/FgHAEBMfHK8?si=MhKMlpCjRPV9cn4s

The Tragedy of Power Politics. 

This skillful interview contains many fresh insights from Professor John J. Mearsheimer.

The positive side of Nationalism can hold together a multicultural Liberal Society.

Aswhere a Liberal believes that a program of economic engagement will bring other states on board and into the fold of democratic countries, a Realist believes that in the absence of any hierarchy and in the uncertainty concerning your neighbours' intentions, Great Powers will be always vying with each other for dominance and control, just to ensure their survival.

In the 1990s when Russia was at its weakest, America chose containment rather than assistance. America could have helped Russia integrate into a new security architecture.

The unipolar moment lasted rather more than a moment, from 1991 to 2017, so younger people [born after 1972] today have no experience of the Cold War (1947 - 1991) and no one has experience of a multi-polar world (America, China, Russia, post 2017).

The Ukraine War started back in the 1990s when America was unchallenged and free to do as it pleased and attempt to convert the world to democracy and contain "the threat" from Russia. The Ukraine war is a vestige of the Cold War and a policy of NATO enlargement eastwards.

Today the West is in two cold wars, plus (not talked about here), the risk of The Middle East becoming the battleground for some very serious proxy wars.

The correct strategy would have been to work with Russia to knock out China, but this is a strategy for a multi-polar world and yet the war with Russia is a result of a unipolar world and unipolar thinking.

War between the three Great Powers is more likely in the South or East China Seas, or Taiwan, than in Central Europe, because the scale of the potential horror in Central Europe is unimaginably greater. The only hope of avoiding direct confrontation between the Great Powers is the threat that it may go nuclear.

The American foreign policy establishment, aka The Blob, calls the shots irrespective of the party in power on The Hill or the president in The White House. As proof, both Trump and Biden did a volte-face, faced with the limitations of their power vis-a-vis The Blob. [This is why many hark back to JFK's famous and powerful peace speech in June 1963 and believe that he was assassinated by The Blob.] Trump armed Ukraine. Biden went back on his promise of engagement. Next time will be no different. The reason - if you are a structuralist like Mearsheimer is that we are now in a multipolar world.

Can balance-of-power Realism work in a multipolar world to prevent war? There will be crises, there may be war, war will be hard to shut down once started, and it is easier to fight in Asia than Central Europe, but perhaps the threat of nuclear will deter....

Read More

STRATEGY IN ACTION

8 December 2023

SUMMARY

This is an old block of flats that is no longer 

up to today's living standards. This is seriously affecting capital and rental values. One way to restore vale is to upgrade the outside and the public areas and facilities, but this would require more money than many of the owners are prepared to put in.

Therefore the problem is how to convince these owners to join and fund a rehab program.

First we need some data : we need to know by how much the building is undervalued and whether the proposed redesign and rehab could pay for itself.

If the case is proven but the proposal won't be passed at the Residents Association, a strategy is needed to split the no vote. Those decidedly for or against can be put to one side, in order to focus on the group of undecideds. An issue which would split this group can be created. Thus a majority in favour of the proposal can be created. 

It is also necessary to bring on board those who do not have the means to pay for the work.

For example, a subsidised loan could be offered, the cost of the subsidy could be added back to project financing costs and shared.

Then a campaign could be organised to canvas support with the waiverers, which if successful will mean the work could go ahead.

PROBLEMS / REQUIREMENTS

There is a problem, because although this block of 120 apartments is old, 30 years old, it is nonetheless in one of the best areas of the city, near to a couple of embassies; the rooms are large by modern-day standards; this is a good location near protected forest, fresh air off the nearby river; opposite a pretty place of worship with a recent by-law requiring any new-build be low-rise; and yet entertainment too a short walk away, being central to the principal gate to this walled city; giving a "rus-in-urbe" feel; and what's more, despite complaints of noise from ongoing apartment modernisations, it is a relatively quiet block with a peaceful mixed population 50-50 local and foreign; service and land charges are low; the property is well run along the "rule of 3Es" - economy, efficiency, effectiveness.

So you would think an attractive premium investment.

But no! The problem is that the per-square-foot (PSF) retail market value, buy or rent, is about half or perhaps 2/3 of the cost PSF in more recent post-2010 blocks. This block cannot compete with modern living standards, it seems.

And yet for these recent blocks, the apartments are smaller; the insulation is less; locations are less favourable, sometimes out of town; charges are certainly higher for a similar standing.

So what can be done about this? 

Evidently the solution is to upgrade the quality of the built environment ie a rehab project, starting with external dec.s, followed by upgrades to the lobby and other public areas; and publicise this improvement to attract warranted attention, increase demand; and obtain more inward investment and up property values and returns.

GOAL

That is the goal then : to raise capital and rental values, from a program of building upgrade, to be publicised on social media. Noting that any proposal for change must be approved by the well-run Residents Association, aka "The Committee".

RISK

The difficulty getting this through the committee is that many of the membership and the committee itself are viscerally opposed to any capital expenditure projects beyond schedules of preventive maintenance and the basic minimum necessary to meet legal requirements.

How to convert a majority against change into a majority in favour of change?

STRATEGY

To get this public areas rehab project through the committee, one way could be to

1. get a list of all owners and tenants and with the Property Manager if available, evaluate the likely attitude of each person, splitting the list into three groups :

- those who would support the project

 - those who would certainly oppose 

- and then a middle group of doubters / undecideds

Focus on the undecideds. (We have little time, there is no point in spending time and stirring up feelings on those already strongly committed.)

2. Find an issue which would split the doubters into those for the proposal and those against.

3. Thus, if you could persuade the committee to consult owners, and you have successfully split the doubters, then you would stand a good chance of your proposal being approved.

What issue could split the undecideds? Who is this group?

CAMPAIGN PLAN

A possible way forward to discuss with fellow activists:

If you know the PSF cost of the rehab, and could value PSF the post-project, then you have a cost-benefit analysis and you know the PSF cost that can be charged back to owners, by majority agreement.

This CBA and chargeback should sell the proposal. (For info, owners and tenants have equal representaion on the Cttee.)

But what if it doesn't? What if the committee doesn't approve the expenditure? What if some owners refuse to pay their share? Here are the sticking points.

A solution might be to offer a subsidy on a loan the Committe can organise, that some owners might need if they are to be convinced them. But offer only to people who've been here for a minimum five years, or who have an income below a certain threshold, or whatever criteria will create a division.

And simply include the cost of this subsidy back in the project financing costs.

Now you can canvas the undecideds, offering them a helpful low-cost subsidy (at zero capex) that will tilt the vote at a Special AGM.

IMPLEMENTATION

to be continued ...

Read More

DESPAIR AT THE FUTURE OF THE WEST

4 December 2023

Just to watch our foolish leaderships throw away what were once good hands. Fills me with despair. 

What can we do with our elites except remove them, how to do that? You judge a tree by its fruits. I don't want their media, their propaganda - I pay for and judge the meal in a restaurant, not the chef!

And if we don't, if we can't get them out of office? What I think about is the real value of my savings - whether inflation and currency collapse, or deflation and stagnation, my savings accumulated over my working life are worth less and less.

The only bright spots have been beating the index (so what? It's real returns that count), and gold (up 6% this year). Plus living in a decent, stable, affordable society, albeit as an outsider.

But the downside is continued destruction of my purchasing power, my culture and my sons' community where they live, drifting into govt.s of control, plus other strengthening foreign centres of power are going to take advantage of Europe and the USA more and more.

UPDATE 5 DECEMBER

It is not you and I that are going to change the world, we've had our chance.

Now it is the turn of the milleniums and gen Z.

But what will they do? Re-invent the past? Throw it over? 

Or perhaps they think they've done it with this Woke nonsense. So we will have another generation to wait?

As those the initiative is with the West! The Russians are rolling in while we make our plans. The Chinese have caught us all up in their web of Belts and Roads. The Americans won't be coming to the rescue any time soon, they've given their horses to the gypsies!

NATO is a paper tiger, Europe is like the Holy Roman Empire before Napoleon invaded, all chocolate box armies and parliaments of stuffed shirts.

You and I saw through this parody years ago! 2008 was it!?

UPDATE 6 DECEMBER

I can confirm from the macro-economics side of my life that companies making alcoholic drinks see their sales rise in times of depression, doubtless more drug abuse too, food abuse, 

declines in the mental and physical health of the people.

So we can expect higher suicide rates too. 

As a result of "the decline of the West". Indeed, we see all around us the decline of western peoples' living standards and the health of the nations.

In fact, a bit of reflection on the ticker-tape of history, the rise and fall of great empires, we see we are in actual historical fact witnessing the usual doom loop. 

Elites are manipulating governments to enrich themselves, 

they are making war on foreign elites thinking they can expand their power and wealth by pillaging their neighbours,

and through standard soothsayer media they spread propaganda at home and abroad to cover this up and keep the populus on board.

The decline is not just material, it's also in our values, which includes our faith in our system of government, ie in democracy itself. This is what happens, and it is entirely predictable, it is what links are past and our present to our future.

“Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times.”

We need to be far more doubting of govt news channels, far more discriminating of who we listen to, and more trusting of our own judgements. The aren't quick fixes to these kind of problems and we should not be brow-beaten by governments into believing that there are - it takes a 20 year long haul to effect profound radical change after which we can expect stability and peace, at least for a long while, during which education and new knowledge & understanding develops, and material wealth increases starting from the treasure taken by the New Empire from the Old.

                           This is the circle of history.

It takes tough times for the hero promising  redemption to emerge. But to get into this sorry state it requires the weak man or men or gov.ts - this is the prerequisite of the strong man, who is the hero. Myths - many cycles of history condensed into a story - going back to the Greeks and doubtless before tell us this story. The hero starts out weak as he has not yet developed his powers. Then through a series of difficult trials with his adversaries he develops strength and skills. He then uses these to overhaul the system and bring peace and prosperity to his people.

Meaning that from all this Mess and Injustice we can expect populist leaders to step forward, wanting to force through tough ideological cleanup programmes of action on root causes. Only outsiders can clean up this mess, the power elite will never voluntarily let go. Outsiders from within or without.

How will these new leaders seize power? They will do it in the usual way: by inciting the populus - mainly younger people who are uninvested and despairing and think they are bullet-proof - to take to the streets.

We can see that the elite won't give up power and wealth, it is the height of naivety to imagine that radical reform can be voted through the Ballot Box, so what else can the people do? 

It is only utopian reform or rebirth that can deal with the final results of greed. Greed that is satisfied in the fiscal process. The people stay happy with welfare and propaganda, while the elite purloin the wealth of the country through corrupt and mediocre politicians. But eventually, it comes to a point where there's so much mess and putrification that it needs radical change. This change can be brought about from within or from without. 

Which is better - radical overhaul from within, or radical overhaul from without? The former is revolution. The latter is war or migration.

"Without" meaning on account of internal weakness, a country gets taken over and becomes part of someone else's empire, a rising empire. 

That's history, it is a circle with knowledge and technology as the only straight lines of progress. 

Knowledge from which our elites understand sweet nothing. 

History from which our elites understand sweet nothing.

Read More

WAR : THE WAY FORWARD

30 November 2023

https://youtu.be/BJx7xoR70h4?si=3Kc6mbqVO1fHcSuM

You've read the panchatantra and understand that war is the natural condition of our species. In  different way, Jan Oberg is saying the same thing from a different point of view. 

https://youtu.be/D_3itcQ9wqQ?si=WuYYi-z1M0ZXLVRq

Salman Rushdie too.

https://www.youtube.com/live/2cmAISDWnL4?si=r6byPknnAf3w6ty4

Mearsheimer is as perplexed as all normally-adjusted people. Despite Rushdie's condensing a thousand years of human  history and wisdom into a hundred words, noone has an answer to making or finding peace today.

1. I follow the news. It seems the neocon narratives are being exposed everywhere across geopolitical histories, eg Minsk and Istanbul are now being unpicked, Israel is seen as having no plan, only a thirst for vengeance's plan. 

The American people won't be had again and next year could present a surprise peace candidate. That's a realistic option and hope.

America doesn't have the initiative on the battlefield in Ukraine, it looks pretty obvious that Ukraine will be fairly and squarely beaten, and with them NATO and America. This will be a sea change for the West and for Russia too. Russia will undoubtedly incorporate Ukraine as it has done with Belarus into its family of nations...Putin is eyeing Transnistria incidentally, something new.

2. The Middle East seems to be overtaking events in Ukraine in the race to see who can get us to WW3 first.

We could see the Arab nations surrounding Israel finally running out of patience and overrunning that place, dragging in America with its fleet anchored offshore. 

Possibly starting in Syria: if America starts in Syria, where it has illegally positioned its forces, then Russia will be affected and may take action; if Russia takes action to defend its interests in Syria and is directly attacked by America, then this will bring in Iran and China.

3. As to Israel and its future, there is no way that Israel could ever accept a two-state solution as it would lose its strategic hinterland in the West Bank and the next day be overrun by its neighbours. It's only options for its security and survival are do peace or die, even though this is not accepted in Israel and never has been. 

I would like to know, how come if there are so many clever people in Israel, they have not learnt how to get on with their neighbours and they do not understand that it's a binary world they accept peace or they die in war.

4. We need a change of leadership and a European security conference and a new Bretton Woods, if we are to avoid the next World War.

Read More

PANCHATANTRA STORIES

30 November 2023

Have you heard of the Panchatantra stories?

I hadn't until I listened to Salman Rushie

https://youtu.be/D_3itcQ9wqQ?si=Z19zsmSlj97KoKnz

https://chat.openai.com/share/bb113c9f-af65-4a40-a6a8-ad48ec4b8a6c

Read More

LOY KRATONG

27 November 2023

The river is full of tiny "kraton" they are called, little mini boats made from a slice of banana trunk, with a candle and a couple of sticks of incense and a few flower heads. 

It's like an Armada of tiny ships floating down the river, there are hundreds and hundreds of them. 

People go to the temple opposite my block to "make merit". Temples are very often built on land by the river. The faithful say a prayer and push out their mini banana boat.

Meanwhile, the sky is filled with these "sky lanterns", a squadron of floating "kourms" they"re called, slowly floating across in bobbing formation.

All set to the continuous crackle of fireworks.

All very lovely.

But the streets are 100% rammed with people, scooters and cars, all over the roads and pavements, no room at all.

Ron and Steward, who run my regular restau called OMG, are beside themselves - they haven't taken a salary in four years!, they live off their UK pension and feed their Thai partners and kids. But now, this will be the third day on which they take 60,000 baht - it's a lot.

Can you imagine what it's like ?!

Read More

REASONS FOR DOLLAR DEVALUATION

24 November 2023

Government debt 33t just a shade below 140% of GDP.

Total country debt a shade below 400% of GDP. Debts that will never be fully paid.

Unfunded government liabilities is at $212 trillion.

$1.8 trillion student loans seeing increasing default, the $2.7 trillion auto and credit card loans likewise.

Commercial real estate collapsing.

Soaring zombie companies bankruptcies.

CLO defaults,

Small and medium regional banks in serious trouble.

Collapsing household savings.

Over stretched household balance sheet.

Stagnant population growth and aging population.

Shortage of skilled workers.

Low labor participation rate.

Stagnant work week hours.

Inflation eating up wage increases.

Sticky inflation.

Reversing fiscal and monetary largesse.

Recession probably already here.

Political chaos next year.

Want more reasons for US dollar devaluation?

Read More

BIDEN CORRUPTION - HOW IS IT BIDEN IS STILL POTUS?

16 November 2023

How come this charlo is still POTUS?

is.gd/hHPhuZ

"Our mission statement is to ensure the efficiency, effectiveness, and accountability of the federal government and all its agencies. We provide a check and balance on the role and power of Washington - and a voice to the people it serves."

The detail summarised:

In February 2014, a Russian Oligarch Sent $3.5 Million to a Shell Company Associated with Hunter Biden and Devon Archer: Russian billionaire Yelena Baturina transferred $3.5 million to Rosemont Seneca Thornton, a shell company.

Hunter Biden was initially hired by Burisma to work as counsel for the company, and Pozharsky and Zlochevsky met with Hunter Biden at a conference in Lake Como in Italy where they decided Hunter Biden would work on the board of directors with Devon Archer.

In April 2014, a Kazakhstani Oligarch Wired the Exact Price of Biden’s Sportscar to a Bank Account Used by Archer and Biden: In February 2014, Hunter Biden met with Kenes Rakishev at a Washington, D.C. hotel.

Hunter Biden received millions of dollars in payments from Yelena Baturina, Burisma, and Kenes Rakishev.

Read More

IS WESTERN SUPPORT FOR ISRAEL AND UKRAINE SUCCEEDING?

13 November 2023

Things are looking very bad. The Russians are butchering the Ukrainians, and along comes Hamas with a jolly trap for Israel. Israel fell in straight away so now we have another bloodbath.

The circumstances are horrific, although this is a military confrontation. What might happen when hostilies cease?

Let's take a look at what these ongoing massacres mean through three lenses. The scale is global: these conflicts are local, between nation-states, almost you might see them as civil wars, but they regional and most importantly, global repercussions. Second, the timeline started five centuries ago: today, we are looking at the West in decline, the unravelling of colonisation. Of course thirdly, there is a moral dimension: we should ask if supporting these causes is ethically correct as our actions will impact our credibility in the negotiating and implementation phases of resolving these conflicts.

THE DECLINE OF THE WEST

Back in the late 60s, we had Edward Säid who captured the West's attitude to Asia in the wor "Orientalism". Orientalism is the idea that the Middle East and Asia was one clump of mysterious underdevelopment that would never change. But now after five centuries of running their worlds, and ober 2,500 years of a culture dating back to the Greeks, it is the turn of "the Global South" to look at "Westernism" and see our decline, see the failures of America and NATO against Russia, see the wasted trillions in failed foreign adventures. 

Meanwhile China finishes off its belt and road and Russia re-industrialises.

America is no longer the "indispensable nation", it has failed at policing conflict situations, indeed it has created them, it has no manifest destiny or ability to rule over us in the name of global security. It listens to no-one, it just sends in the military (rarely its own).

INJUSTICE

Not just bloodbaths and Western decline,  once we were the beacon of justice and fair play, and now we indict Putin while Natanyahu gets a free pass, we sanction Russia for non-respect of Intl law while Israel flouts 70 years of UN resolutions. What was once a boundary dispute is now a war of religion, a clash of civilisations: in the one a negotiated solution was possible, but Islam demands total surrender and Zionism is colonisation of biblical lands for the coming of the messiah. Before 7 October we could have fixed what is for the Arabs and Persians united, the mother of battles to come. But look now at the dogs we've woken up with such complacent and brutal kicks, to the point where now it is uncontrollable. And then there's "the enemy within".

GLOBAL 

It's not obvious that ordinary people nor our elites truly realise that the West is now in the minority and facing an increasingly organised and powerful global majority. These aren't just "talking points". It's not just the Middle East, the Arabs and the Persians: now it's Africa and the rest of Asia and Russia too. It means the West cannot force through to the touchline. America can no longer do what it has been trying to do since the last war which is force its internal policies onto the rest of the world.

Here's a tape of a speech by indonesia's representative to the UN. Indonesia! Who normally wouldn't say boo to a goose!

ONLY SOLUTION IS MILITARY

It is not just military. It's not 48, 67 or 73. Today Israel is risking its homeland, sure, and losing the moral battle, the battle of ideas. Netanyahu has no plan that we know of other than his own salvation, his promise to keep Israel safe is false, and he is up against an organised and global enemy with ideology, strategy, plan, actions and results. 

So it is a time for diplomacy, cooperation, working to find agreed solutions. The military is not the end, it is in service to politics and diplomacy. But I don't think there's anyone in Washington who could state what is the role of a diplomat. I don't think they understand diplomacy. And their goal of world domination is madness these days, I mean ... isn't that obvious? Same same for Israel's revenge.

Because the Middle East had been quiet, as Jake Sullivan observed, doesn't mean that the Israel-Palestine conflict wasn't ruminating away. But even if America would agree to a two-state solution, there are no moderate voices in Israel nor Gaza to lead the negotiations - they are dead or radicalised. And even if a two-state solution were agreed and the 700,000 illegal settlers in the West Bank were cleared things have come to a pretty pass and I think the Arab nations would wipe out the lesser Israel the day after it was reformed, because America will be too weak to back it.

ISRAEL CANNOT SUCCEED ITS MISSION

More practically, the aim of the Israeli operation in Gaza is to destroy Hamas. Really? There's no way they can pull this off unless they commit genocide and kill all Palestinians in Greater Israel.

THE RESULT LONG-TERM WILL BE MORE TERRORISTS AND LESS SECURITY

For each Hamas member that they kill, they create ten more.

This operation gets revenge but doesn't improve Israel's security problem. It just unites the Arab world and the Global Majority against Israel and The West.

The number one priority of any country is its security, but this operation will only reduce Israeli security. 

America's top generals have come through the fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan and they know that the longer this goes on, the more children and women especially that are killed, the more terrorists are recruited.

THE RISK OF WORLD WAR INCREASES

America has forward deployed huge numbers of men and equipment to the area what does this do for the prospects of a third world war?

We can seek a permanent resolution in line with UN Security Council resolutions, or we can seek military solutions.

Read More

UKRAINE IS LOST TO EUROPE

13 November 2023

Ukraine is lost to Europe and the dying EU should conserve contributions from member states for worthwhile projects that enhance our peace and prosperity.

Ukraine has lost this war. It foolishly rejected peace in 2015 and in 2022 and now faces the consequences. The people of Ukraine will realise how idiotic has been their president, who has cost them half a million lives. They will rise up against him. He will flee the country to one of his numerous villas bought with money from American and European taxpayers or from Arms sold into other conflict areas around the world by members of his corrupt oligarchy.

The number one purpose of this war was to get Ukraine into NATO: that will never happen. The idea of Ukraine joining the EU is completely absurd and purely another political dream from our leaders very far out of touch with reality, since Ukraine is at war and in any case is economically completely unviable. Frankly, who would want to take on the burden of Ukraine? And where would they find the money?

The answer is that only Russia is in a position to offer Ukraine a prosperous and peaceful future. There is plenty of room for optimism. Ukraine's future lies in some kind of a rebuild and reindustrialization arrangement with Russia. Russia will see to Ukraine as it did in the 18th century when Katherine the Great and her architect Potemkin built Novo Rossiya.

I would imagine that the east from Odessa up to Kiev will be reintegrated into Russia and the portion that is left, the"rump", can be given to the Poles or can attempt to continue limping along as a state dependent on Moscow.

How can anyone ever have the slightest confidence in our foolhardy politicians? They have put us into the greatest debt we have ever known, they have taken us to two wars now, they have sullied our culture with mass immigration, they struggle with solutions for climate change and they are unable to deal with almost daily civil war in our societies.

We live in poverty, inflation and violence; our health service is non-existent, our schools are falling apart, our defenses are not up to it.

Failure after failure after failure. We need serious politicians who represent our interests. W need a 20 year program to find independence from America and its collapsing Order.

AND EUROPE WILL RISE AGAIN

Amen

Read More

WHY INTELLECTUALS ARE MOSTLY LEFTIES

6 November 2023

This is the title of an extract from a conversation between Roger Scruton and Hamza Yusuf.

https://youtu.be/FYo4KMhUx9c?si=Wfj6jcH9797jumbQ

It's a very good presentation by Roger. He is talking about the appeal of left-wing ideologies today to those seeking a solid framework for their beliefs and ideas, pegs on which they can hang their knowledge. Like the leaves on a tree, if the leaves are the bits of knowledge, an ideology connects all through eventually to one central trunk, which is their ideological belief system. 

This is inevitably lefty thinking, or Marxism if you prefer. Roger says that the day will one day come to anyone with a living brain when that person is able to look back at the time when they had an ideology and realise that today they do not need reasons to explain the way things: things are simply the way they are. Someone who doesn't need reasons any longer is someone who we might call a Conservative.

I think it's not only the attraction of a coherent system of thought for navigating a complex topic - politics, political behaviour -  that pulls in younger people and those with intellectual questions at university.

But I think as well there's this thing called Group Think, which is a bit like an equivalent in the financial world to FOMO, fear of missing out - if you don't join the group then you're likely to be ostracised and see your career cut down. So newbies at the margin join up, for fear others in the core will think they "don't understand", ie have puny intellects, and after that initial commitment they just go into the subject deeper and deeper.

It's a bit like walking into a forest. It gets darker and darker and darker and then eventually you start to walk out of the forest and eventually the daylight begins to return and you start to see the world as it really is, as it always was, when you were a child, you see more objectively, and you can start to make connections and associations of your own.

This FOMO thing is part of how soft power works, as well. If you don't join the neocons then your career as a journalist or a teacher or in high administration or in politics, your career will be shortened because you have ideas that oppose those of the ruling elite, you are therefore against them. There's not much room for nuance lower down in the hierarchy.

It must be annoying to non-extremist contrarians like Roger, never to get a proper hearing for his ideas. Dead now poor chap, coming up to his 4th annif' this Jan24.

Group Think and the lack of diversity of perspectives - not the same things - is very dangerous  ... look at the mess we're in today, for example. Look at the Central Banks. They are all staffed by hundreds upon hundreds of PhDs in economics, all of whom pretty much are neo-Keynesian ie they all think that debt is not so important because the job of the government is to intervene in the market with fiscal and monetary policies that will smooth out short term irregularities, but in reality they can't see the consequences of their Grand Designs of untested ideas, like QE, and hence the mess we're in today. 

It's just the same with all these lefties who think the individual is unimportant and the interests of workers worldwide, as they see them, should prime over the liberty of the individual.

We know that the interests of the individual and the nation will out against the collectivists and the internationalists. We know that you build a wall from the ground up, brick by brick, and don't start at the top!

And we know that the neoclassicists in economics are right when they talk about the need for a balanced budget and for letting individuals in the market combine to decide, each blindly, the way forward.

As to Hegel's "Labour of the Negative", that Roger talks about, yes it's true that Roger's negativists think that the world is all wrong and the only way to put it right is to seize power in order to put into practice your  blueprint for your New Utopia, that's true.

But as I recall Edmund Burke when he looked at the French Revolution in 1789, just like Roger did his in 1968, he concluded that Revolution will fail just as Grand Designs fail, and progress can only really come from incremental change, "in-flight corrections", if you prefer. Roger says he spent his life trying to find out what he didn't like about the mess those students were making of policemen's helmets back in 1968.

The real trouble with the left is its collectivist thinking. It makes grand designs for the future, ignoring present realities and ignoring human nature ; and then when things go wrong it realises that it was because it didn't have perfect knowledge, that is the problem. It's the lack of perfect knowledge that you would need for Grand Designs to work out as planned.

So that's me for the day...

Read More